Drive_XLR8_Lawn_Phix

Testing The 5 Best Crabgrass Killers of 2024

Photo of author

Written By: Mark Marino, a Massachusetts Core Applicator License holder
and owner/operator of Lawn Phix,

No AI pledge. Authored and reviewed by Mark, not robots. Learn more.

Updated on

No comments

LAWN PHIX PRO PICK

After extensive testing, Drive XLR8 came out on top. The liquid form is easy to pour, and its measurement and application are a breeze. I sometimes mix it with Empero to target grassy weeds like nutsedge or combine it with On Deck to take out broadleaf weeds like dandelion. Use 1.45 ounces per gallon of water and watch the results roll in.

Crabgrass breakthrough is simply inevitable, whether you spot it along your driveway or cropped up around frequently-edged landscapes. If it’s not properly killed with crabgrass preventers, it’s sure to get out of hand.

I’ve treated hundreds of acres of lawns with many different post-emergent crabgrass herbicides. But I wondered: which ones actually got the job done, and which ones were mostly just packaging?

I decided to test the effectiveness of these herbicides by applying them to my crabgrass and documenting the results.

After years of empirical testing and photo collecting, I’m sharing my conclusive results.

The top five liquid crabgrass killers are:

  1. Drive XLR8 Herbicide Crabgrass Killer: Best Overall Crabgrass Killer
  2. Acclaim Extra: Best For Killing Larger Crabgrass
  3. Tenacity Herbicide: Best For Killing Younger Crabgrass
  4. Quinclorac 75 DF: Best Affordable Crabgrass Killer
  5. Q4 Plus Turf Herbicide: Best Broad-Spectrum Crabgrass Killer

In this guide, I’m diving into everything you ever needed (or wanted) to know about these five crabgrass killers. I’m also showing the results of my extensive testing so you can see the pictures for yourself.

Top Crabgrass Killers Explained

I got excellent results from all the crabgrass killers on this list.

Let’s get kicked off with the best overall product:

1. Drive XLR8 Herbicide Crabgrass Killer

Drive_XLR8_Lawn_Phix
Drive XLR8

Drive XLR8 Herbicide Crabgrass Killer is one of the highest-rated, best-selling crabgrass herbicides on the market today. It contains over 18% quinclorac as the main active ingredient, undeniably the best herbicide to kill crabgrass plants in over three tiller stages. It is also labeled for many other weeds like white clover, dandelion, Kikuyu grass, and more.

Lawn Phix Review

Drive is the only crabgrass killer I use for my customers and the #1 product I recommend. I experience more crabgrass on new client lawns, and I generally only need to apply one application of Drive XLR8 – even for mature crabgrass plants in the 4+ tiller stage. 

Drive recommends using methylated seed oil (MSO) as a carrier, but since crabgrass generally thrives in the summer, I find this mixture too “hot” and too susceptible to burning good turf. Instead, I lower the pH of my tank water to about 5.0 pH and use Induce pH non-ionic surfactant (NIS) for better (and safer) results.

I sometimes mix Drive XLR8 with Empero (or Sedgehammer) to target crabgrass and nutsedge. These two weeds are prominent during the summer months, so it’s a perfect 1-2 punch.

While the $70 price tag may seem high upfront, the price per application is still quite low.  Including a surfactant, this only costs around $1.60 per gallon. I’ve never found a product that tops it!

Drive XLR8 Herbicide Crabgrass Killer Application Rates

  • Apply 1.45 fluid ounces of Drive XLR8 per 1,000 square feet
  • Do not mow two days before or after applying Drive XLR8
  • Do not water or irrigate for 24 hours after application
  • Do not apply to fine fescue unless it’s part of a blend
  • One-half gallon (64 oz.) covers one acre of established turf
  • Labeled for Bermuda Grass, Buffalograss, and Zoysia (warm-season grass type)
  • Not labeled for St. Augustine, Centipede grass, or Bahiagrass (warm-season grass type)

Drive XLR8 Herbicide Crabgrass Killer Specifications

  • Active ingredient: 18.92% Quinclorac 
  • Application: Backpack sprayer
  • Coverage: Up to 128,000 square feet
  • Product size: 64 ounces (½ gallon)
  • Rates: 0.5 and 1.45 fluid ounces per 1,000 square feet
  • Type: Liquid
  • Use in: Bermuda grass, Kentucky bluegrass, Buffalo grass, Fescue, Ryegrass, Zoysiagrass
  • Weeds targeted: Crabgrass, torpedograss, kikuyugrass, clover, speedwell, and more

Drive is best used when with a Methylated Seed Oil (MSO), but as I mentioned before, a NIS works just as well for me.

Find Drive XLR8 at Do My Own, Lawn Pro, and Amazon.

Before and after photos of testing Drive XLR8; images are seven days apart. This was from a new customer’s lawn in Franklin, MA. The previous lawn care company attempted to seed in late June – the worst time to seed cool-season lawns, particularly in the Northeast. You can see hoe big and mature these crabgrass plants were. Within a week there was visible damage on more than half the plant. A second application two weeks after the first completely cleared this area of crabgrass and weeds.

crabgrass drive
Crabgrass 5 days post-Drive XLR8 application

2. Acclaim Extra

Acclaim Extra Crabgrass Killer
Acclaim Extra

Acclaim Extra Selective Herbicide is a post-emergent herbicide containing the active ingredient Fenoxaprop-p-ethyl. Although it controls all stages of crabgrass, it does its best job on large crabgrass plants at the 4-tiller stage (and larger). If you have well-established crabgrass in your yard, this is the herbicide for you.

Lawn Phix Review

The higher price tag, albeit with great results, makes Acclaim Extra #2 on my list. A pint will treat up to 34 gallons, but I don’t see the benefit of spending more than 2x the cost of Drive XLR8 (a little more than $3.50 per gallon with NIS). 

All that said, Acclaim Extra is an effective crabgrass killer and makes a nice backup to Drive XLR8. 

Side note: I’ve used this with excellent results on Japanese stiltgrass. If you’re fighting both of these aggressive plants, this might be the product for you.

Acclaim Extra Application Rates

Acclaim Extra’s application process depends on the growth stage of your crabgrass.

You can use this chart to determine what that is:

CRABGRASS GROWTH STAGEFL. OZ / 1,000 SQ. FT
Untillered0.30
1-2 tiller stage0.46
3-4 tiller stage0.64
4-5 tiller stage0.90

What does the term ‘tiller’ mean in the context of crabgrass? This video from Do My Own Lawn Care is amazingly informative:

Do My Own Lawn Care – Talking Tiller Stages

Acclaim Extra Specifications

  • Active ingredient: 6.59% Fenoxaprop-p-ethyl 
  • Application: Backpack sprayer
  • Coverage: Roughly 34,782 square feet
  • Product size: 16 ounces
  • Rates: Apply 0.46 ounces to every 1,000 square feet
  • Type: Liquid
  • Use in: Warm-season grasses (Bermuda Grass and Zoysia)
  • Weeds targeted: Barnyardgrass, crabgrass, goosegrass, foxtail, panicum, johnsongrass (seedling), sandbur, sprangletop, and japanese stiltgrass

Find Acclaim Extra at Do My Own, Lawn Pro, and Amazon.

crabgrass acclaim
Crabgrass 5 days post-Acclaim Extra application

3. Tenacity Herbicide

Tenacity_Herbicide__Lawn_Phix

Tenacity Herbicide is extremely effective on younger, more tender crabgrass. This remarkable product contains Mesotrione as its main active ingredient — one of very few herbicides that are safe to apply at seeding. 

You should bleach your one-to-three tiller stage crabgrass within one week of applying Tenacity. However, you may need a second application two weeks later depending on the severity of your infestation.

Lawn Phix Review

I love how little Tenacity turf herbicide is needed per application. Measuring with a syringe can get messy, so I recommend wearing gloves.

Update: there is finally a new squeeze/pour measuring bottle, so you no longer have to fumble with the syringe.

It took two applications for me to kill crabgrass completely. The visual bleaching effects weren’t noticeable until about day seven.

Overall, this is an excellent versatile herbicide easily mixed with Speedzone to create a great “cocktail” against grassy and broadleaf weeds. It’s also good to have on-hand in the event you need to overseed in spring. 

But in the end, I think Mesotrione is best used for killing bentgrass in your yard.

Tenacity Herbicide Specifications

  • Active ingredient: 40% Mesotrione 
  • Application: Backpack sprayer
  • Coverage: Up to 87,120 square feet
  • Product size: 8 ounces
  • Rates: 4 to 8 ounces of product per 30 gallons of water per acre
  • Type: Liquid
  • Use in: Kentucky Bluegrass, Centipedegrass, Buffalograss, Tall Fescue, Perennial Ryegrass, Fine Fescue, and sod-only St. Augustine Grass
  • Weeds targeted: Crabgrass, barnyardgrass, carpetweed, chickweed, clover, dandelion, goosegrass, foxtail, henbit, yellow nutsedge, purslane, thistle, wild carrot, and more

Find Tenacity at Do My Own, Lawn Pro, and Amazon.

crabgrass tenacity
Crabgrass 5 days post-Tenacity application

4. Quinclorac 75 DF

Quinclorac_75_WDG_Lawn_Phix

Quinclorac 75 DF is my top choice for an affordable crabgrass killer and control. The “75” refers to the 75% active ingredient, quinclorac. The “DF” stands for ‘dry flowable,’ which is a granular product that makes a great liquid sprayable herbicide.

Like a few other entries on this list, Quinclorac 75 DF kills crabgrass best with a non-ionic surfactant (NIS).

Lawn Phix Review

The Quinclorac 75 DF worked quickly on the crabgrass. The measurement was trickier, though. The dry flowable ‘pellets’ needed more attention to detail than your average liquid product.

I was conscious of shaking the sprayer constantly to suspend the chemicals in the tank. You can see I needed two applications, but it got the job done nonetheless.

Overall, Quinclorac 75 DF is the best option for those on a more strict budget who don’t mind weighing out the solid product and mixing.

You can also buy Quinclorac in 1.5 L liquid, too. A great, affordable option that kills crabgrass exceptionally.

Quinclorac 75 DF Application Rates

Dissolve one tablespoon per gallon of water, then apply this product directly to your crabgrass.

Quinclorac 75 DF Specifications

  • Active ingredient: 75% Quinclorac
  • Application: Backpack sprayer
  • Coverage: 43,560 square feet
  • Product size: One pound
  • Rates: 1 tablespoon per gallon of water for every 1,361 square feet
  • Type: Granular (liquid form available)
  • Use in: Most residential and commercial lawn APART FROM Bahiagrass, Colonial Bentgrass, Seaside Bentgrass, Centipedegrass, Dichondra, and St. Augustine grass
  • Weeds targeted: Crabgrass, Clover, Foxtail, Dandelion, Black Medic, English Daisy, Morning Glory, Dollarweed, Speedwell, Torpedograss, Kikuyu Grass, Barnyardgrass, Bindweed, Signalgrass, and Violet

Find Quinclorac 75 DF at Do My Own, Lawn Pro, and Amazon.

large crabgrass post crabgrass killer
Crabgrass 10 days post-Quinclorac application

5. Q4 Plus Turf Herbicide

Q4-Plus-Turf-Herbicide-Weed-Killer

Q4 Plus Turf Herbicide is a decent crabgrass killer and all-around herbicide to have on hand. It’s a 4-way herbicide containing quinclorac, sulfentrazone, 2,4-D (dimethylamine salt), and Dicamba. This combo is designed to treat crabgrass, yellow nutsedge, and a long list of commonly found broadleaf and grassy weeds. 

Find Q4 at Do My Own, Lawn Pro, and Amazon.


Q4 Plus Turf Herbicide Application Rates

For broadcast and spot treatments of Q4 Plus Turf Herbicide, use 2.6 to 3.0 ounces of product per gallon per 1,000 square feet. This rate costs about $1.70 per application, which is relatively cost-effective.

Q4 Plus Turf Herbicide Specifications

  • Active ingredient(s): 11.81% dimethylamine salt, 1.49% dimethylamine salt, 8.43% quinclorac, and 0.69% sulfentrazone 
  • Application: Backpack sprayer
  • Coverage: Up to 17,777 square feet
  • Product size: 32 ounces
  • Rates: 2.6 to 3.0 ounces of product per gallon per 1,000 square feet
  • Type: Liquid
  • Use in: Most cold and warm season grasses
  • Weeds targeted: Crabgrass, Barnyard grass, Bull Thistle, Chickweed, Clovers, Crabgrass (large & smooth), Dandelion, Nutsedge, and Signalgrass

View Crabgrass Killers on Amazon

Crabgrass Killer FAQs

What kills crabgrass without killing grass?

When used as directed according to the label, these five crabgrass killers can kill crabgrass at many tiller stages without harming good turf. Chemicals like Fenoxaprop-p-ethyl (Acclaim) and Quinclorac (Drive XLR8) are very effective. Mesotrione (Tenacity) is effective at killing and preventing crabgrass but may temporarily bleach your good grass.

Is crabgrass an annual, biannual, or perennial weed?

Crabgrass is an annual grassy weed and a plant that produces seeds. As crabgrass matures in the summer, it goes to seed and dies off. Seeds overwinter then germinate when soil temps reach 55 degrees. They then emerge as young crabgrass to start the cycle all over again.

When should I put down crabgrass killer?

Always follow the manufacturer’s directions on the labels. If you missed the pre-emergent window and see crabgrass in the spring, it’s best to attack the plant while it is in an early tiller stage. You can spray again into the summer, but follow the application rates/intervals, maximum dosage, and outside temperature warnings (generally under 80-85 degrees).

Will pre-emergent herbicides kill crabgrass?

Yes and no. 

When applied early and correctly, crabgrass pre-emergents prevent seeds from sprouting in your lawn.

But if crabgrass is already visible in your lawn, a pre-emergent will not kill it — a post-emergent crabgrass killer is needed.

Images: Lawn Phix Crabgrass Killer Herbicides

Lawn Phix used crabgrass killer + herbicides

Was the information on this page helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!
Author's Note: this piece has been updated for accuracy since its first publication on

If you buy something from one of our affiliate links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I've used these products and provided an honest opinion on every product I review. This helps support our site and its free content, lawn care guides, and calendars. Learn more.

Photo of author
Author: Mark Marino
My name is Mark Marino, and I am the founder, owner, and operator of Lawn Phix. With a passion for lawn care and turf nutrition for over a decade, I've dedicated countless hours to correcting soil and perfecting lawns. Today, my expertise, backed by formal courses at UMass Extension Pesticide Education, allows me to offer top-tier lawn care services and advice. I am a fully licensed and insured lawn care applicator in Massachusetts, specializing in comprehensive turf nutrition, weed control, and lawn pest control. My license number is AL-0053865. Contact me at [email protected] or +1 (508) 500-8402.

Leave a Comment